- Chapter 1: The Birthday Curse
- Chapter 2: Coffee and Chemistry
- Chapter 3: First Date, First Red Flag
- Chapter 4: Newsflash: Another Body Found
- Chapter 5: Too Good to Be True
- Chapter 6: Wounds and Walls
- Chapter 7
- Chapter 8: A Glimpse Behind the Curtain
- Chapter 9: Weekend in the Woods
- Chapter 10: Ghosts of the Past
- Chapter 11: Kara’s Warning
- Chapter 12: Shadow at the Window
- Chapter 13: Dating Profile Vanished
- Chapter 14: Victim Number Three
- Chapter 15: Locked In
- Chapter 16: Questions Without Answers
- Chapter 17: A Face in the News
- Chapter 18: Trust Games
- Chapter 19: Fingerprints and Fear
- Chapter 20: The Key and the Lock
- Chapter 21: Kara’s Instincts
- Chapter 22: The Missing Year
- Chapter 23: Past in the Picture
- Chapter 24: Closet of Secrets
- Chapter 25: Fourth Girl Down
- Chapter 26: Kara’s Final Call
- Chapter 27: Kara Is Missing
- Chapter 28: What the Camera Saw
- Chapter 29: The Confession That Wasn’t
- Chapter 30: The Worst Discovery,
- Chapter 31: Dead Eyes Open
- Chapter 32: The Spy in Her Pocket
- Chapter 33: The Emails
- Chapter 34: Basement Apartment
- Chapter 35: The Profiler
- Chapter 36: The Girl He Dated Before Me
- Chapter 38: Police Can't Help
- Chapter 39: The Key Copy
- Chapter 40: Behind the Red Door